PHOL DHANYA PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: PHOL🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2024

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

The Meeting of the Board of Directors No. 1/2025 on January 15, 2025, consisting of 9 directors, including 5 independent directors, of which 3 are audit committee members who attended the meeting, considered and assessed the adequacy of the internal control system for the year 2024, referring to the "Internal Control Adequacy Assessment Form" of the Securities and Exchange Commission as a guideline for assessing the company's internal control, which is based on the COSO 2013 framework in all 5 aspects: control environment, risk assessment, control activities, information and communication, and monitoring activities. The Board of Directors agrees with the Audit Committee's opinion, concluding that the internal control system of the company and its subsidiaries is appropriate and sufficient for business operations and in accordance with the principles of COSO 2013, including no material weaknesses in internal control. The Board of Directors is of the opinion that the company has an internal control system in place to monitor and ensure that personnel comply with laws, policies, and various practices, and that transactions with stakeholders are adequate, appropriate, and consistent with changing risks. An appropriate management structure is established, sufficient personnel are provided, and continuous personnel development is promoted, including the provision of equipment, tools, and information technology systems to support operations to achieve the organization's goals and objectives effectively.

The Company’s operations have been in accordance with the internal control framework, whereby the internal control system sufficiency evaluation results in 2024 turned out to be 100%. Furthermore, the Company has improved the information technology system to improve the operations, allowing for fast responses to both internal and external customers, reducing redundancies and errors in work. Staff members are also encouraged to form a learning culture, leading to operations that align with the Code of Conduct and the Corporate Governance Policy.

For the company's auditor, ANS Audit Co., Ltd., by Ms. Kuntida Pasurakun, who audited the quarterly and annual financial statements for 2024, there is no opinion in the audit report that the company has deficiencies in its internal control system.

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO)

Internal Control Policy

The Board of Directors places great importance on an effective and adequate internal control system. It mandates internal controls within the framework of the COSO 2013 international standard, with the Audit Committee overseeing, monitoring, and auditing the company's internal control system. The management team oversees the operational processes, ensuring that all departments participate in the implementation. Adequate personnel are provided, with defined responsibilities and authority. Segregation of duties is implemented for performers, controllers, and approvers to provide checks and balances. Reliable and timely financial and non-financial reporting ensures reasonable assurance of effective organizational management. Under changing circumstances, the company can operate in accordance with its goals and objectives.

The Company has established a good corporate governance policy, including various policies, to comply with laws and relevant regulations. These policies are communicated to employees at all levels for strict adherence. The Company also requires regular reviews and reporting of audit results. The Internal Audit Department is assigned to assess the adequacy and appropriateness of the internal control system annually to ensure that the Company's work processes are efficient, effective, and in accordance with international standards. The key points are summarized below:

1. Control Environment

The Company has established a corporate governance structure consisting of the Board of Directors and sub-committees, including the Audit Committee, Risk Management and Sustainability Committee, and Nomination and Remuneration Committee. Each committee has clearly defined charters and roles and responsibilities to oversee the organization in achieving its business objectives, maximizing shareholder value, and complying with the Corporate Governance Policy, Code of Business Conduct with honesty, integrity, and transparency, as well as the Code of Conduct for Directors, Executives, and Employees appropriately. The Company oversees transactions with related parties or those that may have conflicts of interest and is responsible to society as a whole. Senior management is responsible for overseeing the management of various functions and communicating the organization's goals to employees at least once a year to guide all employees towards the organization's objectives. The Company allocates resources adequately and has a human resource management system that supports the achievement of organizational goals and objectives. The Company also oversees and manages its subsidiaries to have an internal control system appropriate to the nature of their business, similar to the parent company.

2. Risk Assessment

The Company has established a risk management policy as a key policy with the objective of identifying, assessing, and managing foreseeable risks appropriately or at a level acceptable to the organization to support the achievement of corporate goals. The Company has appointed a Risk Management and Sustainability Working Group to manage risks at the management level, including ESG risks. The Working Group comprises senior executives from each business group and is chaired by the Chief Executive Officer. It is responsible for assessing internal and external risk factors covering all aspects that may affect the Company's objectives and business operations. It fosters a risk management culture within the organization, establishes risk management plans and measures linked to corporate strategies, and integrates them into the operational level. The Working Group monitors the risk management of various departments and reports the results to the Risk Management and Sustainability Committee and the Board of Directors on a quarterly basis. It also assesses the adequacy of the internal control system appropriately.

The performance results of enterprise risk management are presented in the "Risk Management" section.

3. Control Activities

The Company has established control activities to respond to risks appropriately and sufficiently to be at an acceptable level, starting from setting policies and guidelines for proper and appropriate implementation. It also establishes operational control measures in the form of documents such as work regulations, operating procedures, and manuals, including information security management that aligns with the Company's information technology security policy.

In addition, the Company has established clear authorization of power for the Company's operations and segregation of duties for appropriate checks and balances, such as separating approval functions from accounting and data recording functions, and separating asset custody functions. The Company promotes employee awareness of the importance of strict compliance with relevant rules and regulations to ensure the effectiveness of the internal control system as intended. The Company monitors the performance through the Chief Executive Officer and/or the Managing Director of the subsidiary or the authorized representative.

The Company has established a strict policy on related party transactions, in accordance with the regulations of the SEC and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, which stipulates that interested parties in such transactions are not entitled to vote on the approval of such transactions. The policy also mandates that the pricing and terms of related party transactions be determined as if they were conducted with unrelated parties (At arm's length basis). Additionally, the Company has a confidentiality policy, data retention policy, and internal information usage policy to prevent conflicts of interest, prioritizing the best interests of the Company. In conducting various transactions, the Company has strict monitoring measures in place to ensure that such transactions are carried out in accordance with the procedures and have passed the approval process as prescribed.

4. Information and Communication

The Company prioritizes an efficient and comprehensive information and communication system throughout the organization, enabling all employees to access communication channels. There is also communication from top management to employees at all levels to drive the organization in the same direction. The Company has established a standardized data storage system with processes for storing and backing up important data in accordance with relevant laws, including compliance with the Personal Data Protection Act B.E. 2562. In addition, to ensure accurate and adequate information communication for decision-making by the Board of Directors, management, shareholders, and stakeholders, the Company has an accounting policy based on generally accepted accounting standards appropriate for the business. There is proper and auditable accounting record keeping and documentation. Meeting invitations with supporting documents are prepared and sent to the Board of Directors for review at least 7 days in advance. The Company Secretary provides information or suggestions in accordance with various rules and regulations, oversees the activities of the Board of Directors, and ensures that the Board's resolutions are implemented. The Company Secretary also prepares and maintains important documents, including the Directors' Register, Board of Directors' meeting minutes, Board of Directors' meeting reports, shareholders' meeting invitations, and shareholders' meeting reports, in a systematic manner for shareholders to review as appropriate. The Company also defines access rights to confidential information.

In addition, the Company has established a policy for disclosing company information to shareholders and investors in a complete, accurate, adequate, and timely manner to ensure that all parties have equal access to information. The Company has also established channels for whistleblowing and complaints, along with measures to protect whistleblowers, as well as other guidelines, which are published on the company's website. www.pdgth.com Investor Relations

5. Monitoring Activities

The Board of Directors monitors and oversees the Company's operations to ensure that the organization can achieve its objectives. In 2024, the Board of Directors held 8 meetings, including 1 meeting without executive directors. The management team holds monthly meetings to monitor performance against targets and the implementation of the corporate strategy plan approved by the Board of Directors. The meetings also address any issues that may arise and adjust the operational plan to align with the changing circumstances. The Board of Directors jointly considers and provides recommendations for problem-solving, with continuous reporting of implementation results. The Board also monitors the results of internal audit reviews on a quarterly basis to ensure that internal controls are effective and appropriate for the changing environment. If any deficiencies are found, the responsible parties are required to develop and implement timely corrective actions. The management is responsible for overseeing compliance with the internal control system, while the internal audit function conducts independent audits, monitoring, and reporting to the Audit Committee on a quarterly basis for further reporting to the Board of Directors.

Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)000

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

No

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3159

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

In order to implement good governance procedures, the Board of Directors has established an independent internal audit unit that reports on internal audit results, performs its duties to the Audit Committee, and reports to the Chief Executive Officer. The internal audit unit is responsible for systematically assessing and improving the effectiveness of the Company's internal control system, risk management system, and corporate governance processes, promoting the achievement of organizational objectives and goals, preparing operational and audit performance reports, and presenting recommendations or material weaknesses to the Chief Executive Officer and the Audit Committee on a quarterly basis for the Board of Directors' acknowledgment.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

The Audit Committee is responsible for considering and approving the appointment, removal, transfer, and performance evaluation and compensation of the Head of Internal Audit of the Company. The Audit Committee also supports the Head of Internal Audit to participate in training, seminars, and continuous professional development related to internal audit practices. The Audit Committee also sets appropriate internal audit plans in accordance with the current situation, including changes in laws and regulations.

The Audit Committee has resolved to appoint Ms. Siriporn Ninklum, Head of Internal Audit, as the Head of Internal Audit of the Company and to act as Secretary of the Audit Committee. The Audit Committee has considered and deemed that Ms. Siriporn Ninklum is qualified, knowledgeable, capable, and experienced in accounting and internal audit for over 10 years. She understands the Company's business activities and operations and has been consistently trained and developed in internal audit practices. She is suitable and adequate to perform the duties of the Head of Internal Audit of the Company.

In 2024, the Audit Committee has considered and assigned Dharmniti Internal Audit Co., Ltd., an independent external auditor, to work with the Company's internal audit unit to conduct an audit of the operations of the units according to the annual audit plan approved by the Audit Committee.

Details of the qualifications and training of the Head of Internal Audit are shown in "Attachment 3 Details of the Head of Internal Audit".

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
Phol Palladium Co., Ltd. Juristic PersonDistributor of Occupational Safety, Health, and Environment Products as well as other related products to focus on government agencies and state enterprises customer.

A subsidiary company. The Company holds 99.99% of the register and paid-up capital of Phol Palladium Co., Ltd. There are the common director and executive, namely Miss Prapaipit Wiriyabubpha and Mr.Paradorn Parepatara

2024-12-31T00:00
Phol Entech Co.,Ltd.Juristic PersonDistributor of Occupational Safety, Health, and Environment Products as well as other related products to focus on government agencies and state enterprises customer.

An indirect subsidiary company, held by Phol Palladium Co.,Ltd. in the proportion of 99.99% of the register and paid-up capital. There are the common director and executive, namely General Chaiwat Satondee and Mr. Pornsak Chunhajinda.


2024-12-31T00:00
Pholdhanya (Cambodia) Co., Ltd. Juristic PersonCessation of business operations

A subsidiary company. The Company holds 100% of the register and paid-up capital of Pholdhanya (Cambodia) Co., Ltd. (Cessation of business operations)

2024-12-31T00:00
B&P Agri Product Co.,Ltd. Juristic PersonThe business of selling coconut water, coconut meat and processed products made from coconut.

A related company. There is the common director, namely Assoc. Prof. Dr. Ekachidd Chungcharoen, holding shares 99.99% of the register and paid-up capital of B&P Agri Product Co.,Ltd.

2024-12-31T00:00
BJC HEAVY INDUSTRIES PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDJuristic PersonThe company engages in the engineering service, which provides manufacturing and installation services for the equipment use in production process of the heavy industry plant.

A related company. There is the common director, namely Assoc. Prof. Dr. Ekachidd Chungcharoen and Mr. Noppadol Dheerabutrvongkul

2024-12-31T00:00
THAI AGRO FRESH CO.,LTD.Juristic PersonEngaged in the business of selling agricultural raw materials

A related company. There is the common director, namely Mr. Wisarute Srirojanakul.

2024-12-31T00:00
Loy Phol Joint VentureJuristic PersonEngaged in the business of construction of water treatment and environmental projects.

Phol Entech Co, Ltd, an inditect subsidiary of the Company, is doing a joint venture business with Loy Corp Company Limited, named Loy Phol Joint Venture with the objective to have the waste management project in Ban Kraud municipality with the investment capital of THB 8 million

2024-12-31T00:00
Phol SK Joint VentureJuristic PersonEngaged in the business of construction of water treatment and environmental projects.

Phol Entech Co,Ltd, an indirect subsidiary of the Company, is doing a joint venture business with SK Tech 999 Company Limited, namely SK Joint Venture with the objective to construct the water distribution system by using solar, Department of Water Resources with the investment capital of THB 2 million.

2024-12-31T00:00
Thai Biolex Co., Ltd. Juristic PersonManufacturer and distributor of natural extracts and plant seed oils.

A related company. There are the common major shareholders, namely Mr. Chavalit Wangthamrong, major shareholders of the Company who is director and holding shares 27.77% of the register and paid-up capital of Thai Biolex Co., Ltd. And Mr. Thanya Wangthamrong, Director and major shareholders of the Company, holding shares 22.22% of the register and paid-up capital of Thai Biolex Co., Ltd.

2024-12-31T00:00
SK Tech 999 Co,Ltd.Juristic PersonConstruction contractor, solar panel installation

A related company, Phol Entech Co,Ltd, the company’s subsidiary, is doing a joint venture business with SK Tech 999 Company Limited namely SK Joint Venture.

2024-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
9999700.0 · Necessity: The Board of Directors reached a resolution to incorporate a subsidiary with the objective of distributing products to the public sector and state enterprise customers to expand the customer base. In 2024, the Board of Directors reached a resolution to increase the registered capital of a subsidiary from 1,000,000 Baht to 10,000,000 Baht to enhance opportunities of acquiring projects with higher value, whereby the company invested in common stocks based on the existing proportion, equivalent to the investment capital of 9,999,700 Baht. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 999970.0 · Nature of transaction: Investment in the Subsidiary · Audit committee opinion: To serve as a funding for the group of companies’ restructuring and increased business opportunities. · As of year before yesteryear: 999970.0 · 6328283.0 · Necessity: The Company sold goods to the Subsidiary as normal business operation with the policy of selling goods to the Subsidiary at the cost price with an additional profit of margin 5-15%. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 5385395.0 · Nature of transaction: The Company sold goods to the Subsidiary · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 9239570.0 · 3132472.0 · Necessity: The Company sold goods to the Subsidiary as normal business operation with the policy of selling goods to the Subsidiary at the cost price with an additional profit of margin 5-15%. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 1916250.0 · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables in the Subsidiary · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 3852939.0 · 3421479.0 · Necessity: The Company purchased goods from the Subsidiary as normal business operation with the policy at the cost price with an additional profit of margin 5-15%. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 2483617.0 · Nature of transaction: The Company purchased goods from the subsidiary · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 2256398.0 · 952204.0 · Necessity: The Company purchased goods from the Subsidiary as normal business operation with the policy at the cost price with an additional profit of margin 5-15%. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 6150.0 · Nature of transaction: Trade payables in the Subsidiary · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 13977.0 · 1560000.0 · Necessity: The Company charges management fee from subsidiary from use of personnel in the support departments of the Company for its operation, such as accounting, finance, human resources, information technology including the equipment of the Company amount to 130,000 baht per month. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 1560000.0 · Nature of transaction: Management fee income · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was reasonable; because it is the expense of the subsidiary which the company holds 99.99% of shares. · As of year before yesteryear: 1560000.0 · 71841.0 · Necessity: The Company purchased goods from the Subsidiary to used as demonstration products, as normal business operation with the policy at the cost price with an additional profit of margin 5-15%. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: The Company purchased assets from the subsidiary · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
0.0 · Necessity: The Board of Directors approved to establish the subsidiary company with objective of doing business regarding to the water management system for consumption. The subsidiary has continuously accumulated operating losses, in 2022, the directors consider on having full the allowance for impairment losses in the subsidiary according to the accounting standard. (49,999,970 Baht) In 2024, the Board of Directors reached a resolution to adjust the shareholding structure in a subsidiary by divesting 99% shares of Phol Water Co., Ltd. to a subsidiary Phol Palladium Co., Ltd. Hence, Phol Water Co., Ltd. changed the status of a subsidiary to an indirect subsidiary, and Phol Water Co., Ltd. has its name changed to Phol Entech Co., Ltd. · Description: Investment in the Subsidiary 49,999,970 Baht Allowance for impairment 49,999,970 Baht Net-Investment in the Subsidiary 0 Baht · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Investment in the Subsidiary-net · Audit committee opinion: The provision was in accordance with the accounting standard. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 883341.0 · Necessity: The Company sold goods to the Subsidiary as normal business operation with the policy of selling goods to the Subsidiary at the cost price with an additional profit of margin 5-15%. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 86158.0 · Nature of transaction: The Company sold goods to the Subsidiary · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 94936.0 · 712814.0 · Necessity: The Company sold goods to the Subsidiary as normal business operation with the policy of selling goods to the Subsidiary at the cost price with an additional profit of margin 5-15%. · Description: -The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of yesteryear: 12521.0 · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables in the Subsidiary · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 7544.0 · 170200.0 · Necessity: The company hired the Subsidiary to operate the water treatment as normal business operation with the policy of selling goods and services to the Subsidiary at the cost price with an additional profit of margin 5-15%. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 79990.0 · Nature of transaction: The Company purchased goods and services from the subsidiary · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 121500.0 · Necessity: The company hired the subsidiary to provide services for wastewater treatment, which is a main business, at the price agreed in the contract. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 313535.0 · Nature of transaction: Cost of water treatment system installation · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 1254140.0 · 3000000.0 · Necessity: The company provided short-term loans to the Subsidiary by issuing a promissory note to use for working capital in operation, which is repayable at call and with interest rate 5.10 per annum. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 8000000.0 · Nature of transaction: Short-term loans-Promissory Note · Audit committee opinion: To support for a subsidiary in which the Company holds 99.99% of shares. · As of year before yesteryear: 25876000.0 · 1000000.0 · Necessity: The company provided short-term loans to the Subsidiary by issuing a promissory note to use for working capital in operation, which is repayable at call and with interest rate 5.10 per annum. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 19736000.0 · Nature of transaction: Short-term loans receivable · Audit committee opinion: To support for a subsidiary in which the Company holds 99.99% of shares. · As of year before yesteryear: 17676000.0 · 598592.0 · Necessity: The company provided short-term loans to the Subsidiary by issuing a promissory note to use for working capital in operation, which is repayable at call and with interest rate 5.10 per annum. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 1051222.0 · Nature of transaction: Interest · Audit committee opinion: To support for a subsidiary in which the Company holds 99.99% of shares. · As of year before yesteryear: 944471.0 · 5370.0 · Necessity: The Company hired a subsidiary to replace the water purifier filter in the office at the agreed price. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Repair and maintenance expenses · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 5400.0
0.0 · Necessity: The Company and its subsidairy sold goods to the related company at the market price, which is normal business operation. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 41720.0 · Nature of transaction: The Company sold goods to the related company · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 20750.0
49660.0 · Necessity: The Company sold goods to the related company, which is normal business operation. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 168210.0 · Nature of transaction: The Company sold goods to the related company · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · 53136.0 · Necessity: The Company sold goods to the related company, which is normal business operation. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables in the Subsidiary · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
205647.0 · Necessity: The Company sold goods to the related company, which is normal business operation. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: The Company sold goods to the Subsidiary · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
8130360.0 · Necessity: The Company and its subsidairy sold goods to the related company at the market price, which is normal business operation with the policy at the cost price with an additional profit of margin 5%. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 8845815.0 · Nature of transaction: The Company sold goods to the related company · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.0 · Necessity: A subsidiary: Phol Water Co., Ltd., in collaboration with Loy Corp Co., Ltd., signed an agreement to incorporate Loy Phol Joint Venture with the objective of executing the construction of a waste disposal center, Baan Kruad Subdistrict Municipality, under an investment capital stated in the agreement of 8 million Baht. In 2024, Loy Phol Joint Venture has paid back the entire sum of the investment capital to Phol Water Co., Ltd. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 8000000.0 · Nature of transaction: Investment in joint ventures · Audit committee opinion: It is the joint venture business according to the investment condition · As of year before yesteryear: 8000000.0 · 1500000.0 · Necessity: The subsidiary (Phol Water Co, Ltd) provides short-term loans as per the joint venture agreement with amount of THB 3 million and interest rate of 10% per year. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 1500000.0 · Nature of transaction: The subsidiary provides short-term loans to related company · Audit committee opinion: It’s normal transactions according to the joint venture agreement. · As of year before yesteryear: 2940000.0 · 0.0 · Necessity: The subsidiary (Phol Water Co, Ltd) provides short-term loans as per the joint venture agreement with amount of THB 3 million and interest rate of 10% per year. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Short-term loans receivable · Audit committee opinion: It’s normal transactions according to the joint venture agreement. · As of year before yesteryear: 2940000.0 · 0.0 · Necessity: The subsidiary (Phol Water Co, Ltd) provides short-term loans as per the joint venture agreement with amount of THB 3 million and interest rate of 10% per year. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 257250.0 · Nature of transaction: Interest · Audit committee opinion: It’s normal transactions according to the joint venture agreement. · As of year before yesteryear: 122500.0 · 7000.0 · Necessity: Operating expense that subsidiary paid for the joint venture company and claimed back later is considered a normal operation. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other receivable · Audit committee opinion: It’s normal transactions according to the joint venture agreement. · As of year before yesteryear: 119100.0
0.0 · Necessity: Phol Water Co,Ltd, the company’s subsidiary does a joint venture business with SK Tech 999 Company Limited, namely SK Joint Venture with the objective to construct the water distribution system by using solar, Department of Water Resources with the investment capital of THB 2 million. In 2023, Phol SK Joint Venture returned capital the subsidiary in the entire amount. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Investment in joint ventures · Audit committee opinion: It is the joint venture business according to the investment condition. · As of year before yesteryear: 2000000.0 · 13438579.0 · Necessity: A subsidiary: Phol Entech Co., Ltd., entered into a project execution agreement in water management to a joint venture, which is considered normal business operations based on the contractual conditions mutually agreed upon. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: The subsidiary of the Company sold goods to the joint ventures · Audit committee opinion: It is the joint venture business according to the investment condition · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 2647227.0 · Necessity: A subsidiary: Phol Entech Co., Ltd., entered into a project execution agreement in water management to a joint venture, which is considered normal business operations based on the contractual conditions mutually agreed upon. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Trade receivables · Audit committee opinion: It is the joint venture business according to the investment condition · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.0 · Necessity: A subsidiary: Phol Water Co., Ltd., granted a short-term loan to Phol SK Joint Venture based on the joint venture agreement, with the financial limit of 1 million Baht and 15% interest rate per year. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 1500000.0 · Nature of transaction: Short-term loans to joint ventures · Audit committee opinion: It is the joint venture business according to the investment condition · As of year before yesteryear: 1550000.0 · 0.0 · Necessity: A subsidiary: Phol Water Co., Ltd., granted a short-term loan to Phol SK Joint Venture based on the joint venture agreement, with the financial limit of 1 million Baht and 15% interest rate per year. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 30822.0 · Nature of transaction: Interest · Audit committee opinion: It is the joint venture business according to the investment condition · As of year before yesteryear: 57329.0 · 0.0 · Necessity: A subsidiary: Phol Water Co., Ltd. charged administrative fees from the joint venture from the use of shared resources in supporting functions; accounting, finance, basic information in operations and relevant equipment. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 455000.0 · Nature of transaction: Other Income · Audit committee opinion: It is the joint venture business according to the investment condition · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
68980.0 · Necessity: The subsidiary;Phol Entech Co.,Ltd. (formerly Phol Water Co.,Ltd.) sold goods to the related company, which is normal business operation. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: The subsidiary of the Company sold goods to the related company · Audit committee opinion: The transaction was the normal trading transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 620410.0
2000000.0 · Necessity: A subsidiary: Phol Entech Co., Ltd. (formerly Phol Water) granted a short-term loan to the joint venture partner, Phol SK, with an interest rate of 15% per year. The principal is to be settled with the interests by June 4, 2025. This short-term loan is guaranteed by the joint venture directors and the directors’ land is put on mortgage. · Description: - · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Short-term lone to joint venture partner · Audit committee opinion: This is a loan granted to a joint venture to execute the 3 construction projects of the water distribution system. The projects are now completed. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
0.0 · Necessity: The subsidiary company was established in Cambodia. The subsidiary reported loss earnings over capital and and ceased its operations, in order to be in accordance with the accounting standard, there was a necessity to have an allowance of impairment. · Description: Investment in the Subsidiary 6,770,686 Baht Allowance for Impairment 6,770,686 Baht Net investment in the Subsidiary 0 Baht · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Investment in subsidiary-net · Audit committee opinion: The provision was in accordance with the accounting standard. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.0 · Necessity: These are trade accounts receivable from sales of products and other receivables from short-term loans to subsidiary, which are normal business operations, however, The Susidairy reported loss earnings over capital and ceased its operations. Thus, in order to be in accordance with the accounting standard, there was a necessity to have full allowance for doubtful account. · Description: Trade and other receivables 7,354,57 Baht Less Allowance for doubtful accounts 7,354,57 Baht Trade and other receivables -net 0 Baht · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: trade and others receivable-net · Audit committee opinion: The provision was in accordance with the accounting standard. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0

Policy & Future Trends

Policy, Measures & Approval Process

The Board of Directors set the policy and guidelines of connected transactions and also set measurements and procedures for the connected transactions between the company and subsidiary or joint ventures or any person with the potential conflict of interest through the process of verification, balance of power and the accurate disclosure of information in order to make the decision under transparency on the connected transactions that have the maximum benefits to the company and shareholders and be in accordance with the Security and Exchange Act, the regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand and the Securities and Exchange Commission as well as related law, rules and regulation. Procedures of the approval of the transaction are as follow;

1. Normal business transaction: In case there is the connected transactions between the Company and the related parties, parties with conflict of interest, interest or future conflict of interest, the Company considers the trading terms that must be similar to those terms a reasonable business person would be expected to enter into with other parties in general in similar circumstances with an equal bargaining power, free of any undue pressure as a result of a person being a director, executive or related person and normal trading terms or market price conditions that are under reasonable condition and accountable. The management can do the normal operation in accordance with measures and procedures that the Board of Directors approved and prepares the summary report to the Audit Committee in every quarter such as sales and services. The Company considers based on general trading terms and the terms that must be similar to those with other people or general customers; for example, using cost-plus pricing of 5%-15% as operating criteria.

2. Transactions supporting normal business: (apart from item no.1), in case for approval of the related-party transactions or connected transactions that are not normal trading transactions, the Company proposes to ask the consideration from the Audit Committee on the necessity and appropriateness of the transaction. In case of the Audit Committee does not have relevant expertise to consider the proposed transaction, the Company shall arrange for an expert such as an independent auditor or appraiser, to provide an opinion on the proposed transaction for further consideration of the Board of Directors or the shareholders, as the case may be, to approve the proposed transaction before implementation. A person with the potential conflict of interest in the proposed transaction shall not be allow to vote or approve the proposed transaction as

- Transactions supporting normal business including lease or rental transactions, the Company shall consider based on general trading terms, and the compensation value can be calculated from the assets or the underlying value.

- Transactions relating to products or services such as investment or sales of investment, the Company shall appraise the total value of compensation or the book value or the market value of products or services, whichever is higher.

- Transactions receiving financial assistance such as loans or guarantees including offer and/or receipt of financial assistance, the Company may consider with fair and generates the optimal benefits to the Company; for example, financial cost/interest rate or the cost-plus pricing of 2% based on general trading terms that are reasonable.

- Resource sharing including assets, human resources or related and/or connected expenses, the Company considers the cost management on expense to reflect the actual cost with fair and transparency.

Future Trends in Related Party Transactions

In the future, if the company has to do the connected transactions regarding to the normal business transactions or normal business support transactions with subsidiary, joint venture or any person with the potential conflict of interest, the company sets the policy of connected transactions with the conditions, which are similar to the normal business operated in the market that the price can be comparable with the price applied for the external customers, which is in accordance with the principals approved by the Board of Directors and in compliance with Securities and Exchange Act B.E. The company should strictly comply with the agreement as well as set the clear and fair pricing and conditions, which do not lead to the benefit transfer.

In case of the new connected transaction or the changes in price and condition, the internal audit team audits and prepares the reports to the Board of Directors for reviewing and providing the comments on the appropriateness and reasonableness of the connected transactions on quarterly basis. In case that the normal business transactions and normal business support transactions has the different condition from normal commercial transactions or other connected transactions, the company follows the policy and guidelines of connected transactions and complies with the measurement and procedures of approval for connected transactions before the transaction date.

The Company will footnote the connected transaction to the financial statement audited by the Company’s auditor and disclose the related-party transactions or connected transactions in annual registration statement and annual report (Form 56-1 One Report)

Contents